talia morgan

Actually, real sex is a lot like porn

The common refrain that “real sex is not like porn” is wildly misleading.

When I first saw porn on the internet, the main thing that freaked me out about it was that the performers moved too fast and made what amounted to animal noises. It looked vulgar and gross. Surely I would eventually require a real person to sate my appetites, but we would do it in a dignified way.

Reader, we did not. For the benefit of my virgin and alien audience, gross noises and jerky motions and slimy textures are not only a realistic depiction of human coitus, but essential to the functionality of the act.

The right thing for me to hear would have been “real sex basically is like porn, but it’s not a big deal. Either you participate in the storied tradition of getting off on how disgusting it is, or you get used to it by the 3rd time.”


What do “sex educators” and scolds mean by “real sex is not like porn?”

  • There are no lights, cameras, or fluffers. You don’t have to do uncomfortable sex positions that photograph well, it’s a tragedy if your stepbrother or the cop arresting you makes advances, and if your partner has hentai anatomy they should see a doctor.

    • Obviously true but not what anyone is talking about. Sometimes, when pressed into a corner on more speculative points, people retreat to pretending this is what they meant.

  • The monetary incentives and parasitic attention patterns of OnlyFans, livestreams, etc. are absent. Your partner is, broadly, not just putting on a show for you.

    • This is true and important, but doesn’t apply to videos of people fucking. The phrase “real sex is not like porn” predates camgirls’ mainstreaming and fansites’ existence.

  • Porn is devoid of connection, attunement, and chemistry.

    • I hear this a lot from people in embodiment or tantra scenes. With all due respect, it is an easy thing to say if you’ve never done sex work. If you have, you know that sure, most of it is just a slog, but humans are humans and chemistry has a way of showing up when you’re least expecting it. (The opening of Barbara Carrellas’s Urban Tantra—the only book about sex anyone should bother reading—is a beautiful description of this.) The conversation should be about developing enough body language literacy to tell which scenes are which, a skill that so happens to apply to real sex.1

What people almost always mean by “porn is not like real sex” is that porn is inherently sexist, rough, and violent. For now, let’s leave aside the question of whether mainstream porn featuring horny, enthusiastic girls is really misogynistic, when half the women on any given passenger flight are reading werewolf mafia boss kidnapping smut.

Yes, most mainstream porn occupies an awkward middle point between gentle, cuddly sex and actual BDSM, with few of the advantages of either. (There is a good chance that your troubled teens have also noticed this and prefer romantic amateur porn, but are too embarrassed to tell you.)

Yes, people are not asking for consent every second. Too bad. Nobody has ever verbal consented as hard as the sex educators of the mid-2010s wanted, and nobody ever will. What you do in the real world is learn to read body language and telegraph your motions. You should ask, in words, about choking and anal. But for most anything else in mainstream vanilla porn, you can get pretty far by placing your body in the right spot for some sex act, then waiting to see how your partner responds before you follow through.2

A better, if less catchy, phrase is “real sex can be as much or as little like porn as you want.” If you are attractive and basically pleasant person, you’ll have choices. No matter what the scolds tell you, women who sincerely enjoy anal and men capable of pounding you hard for an hour straight are out there, in great enough numbers that you will find one eventually. There are plenty of people capable of appreciating softness and gentleness, too, even young straight men.

If anything, your prospects of finding someone sexually compatible are actually much better than random chance, good enough that us mids have a fighting chance. This is because sexual preferences do not arise in a vacuum. There’s a cluster of things like {adrenaline seeking, novelty seeking, ADHD, muscle armoring} that are all getting at one underlying trait. (I don’t really want to get into the tiresome “is it childhood trauma” dispute—my take is that trauma makes the naturally predisposed much more like this, and the naturally sensitive much less like this, and everyone varies over the course of their life, anyway.) This cluster basically predicts how much intensely stimulating people want sex to be.

For the most part, people sort themselves correctly by living out their needs for intensity, though it can take a very long time to get there. Dating apps throw you into the mix with a bunch of randos, but your acquaintances and friends-of-friends, who have similar hobbies and general pace of life, are going to be more compatible with you than you’d expect. It’s a pretty easy thing to scope out on early dates, too (c.f. old OkCupid’s “would you find the apocalypse exciting” question), long before you can ask very personal questions about sex vibes that your date may not have a good answer to. There are still a lot of ways to be incompatible (whether intensity manifests as porn-iness or BDSM or something else, being both tops or both bottoms, some people just being bad at sex or indifferent to their partner’s pleasure), but mentally and physically healthy adults should have a lot of flexibility in what they can do with a person they love. You just have to figure out your priorities. Do you want something else (6’4”, Anthropic equity, within 5 IQ points of you and preferably below), or do you want to get off?

1

If you don’t want to see dead-eyed, disconnected women at all (good life choice), stick to heavy BDSM porn. Seriously. The more intense it is, the stronger selection effects are in place to keep out people who don’t get anything out of it.

2

I do not recommend trying this with people you suspect are really bad at standing up for themselves.