Prove You Are Worthy to Post About Diets
People make a lot of claims about digestion, nutrition, and diet on the internet. Most people should ignore it all and enjoy their slopbowls in peace.
If you have chronic digestive issues, you will unfortunately need to listen to some of them. It is helpful, then, to have a heuristic to tell the iconoclastic geniuses apart from the grifters and bullshitters.
I end up with a pretty similar strategy to what I do when I see or hear random claims about finance (e.g. on Twitter.) I keep some questions in my head that test basic understanding, then either ask the person or, if I feel like I have enough data, imagine how they would answer. (My go-to is “explain how a market maker makes money, and under what conditions they do well or poorly.”) This is obviously not perfect, and smart domain experts often say things that are totally wrong. But it’s enough to relegate Flash Boys to entertainment, and that is pretty helpful.
Some of these questions have objectively correct answers, others are more of an opportunity to say something stupid that hopefully, the person you’re talking to will pass up. “I don’t know” is a wonderful answer.
How long does food take to pass through the alimentary canal? How long does it spend in different places/stages?
If digestion takes so long, why might one race to the toilet an hour or two after eating spicy ramen?
How much do cooking, temperature, seasoning and flavoring, food processing, meal timing, etc. affect hunger and digestion? Do you primarily think in units of ingredients, recipes/foods-as-eaten, or something else?
What are the mechanisms of acid reflux and bile reflux? How does each one feel?
Similar re: digestion being too slow or too fast
What are the causes of the obesity/diabetes/heart disease crisis? For the ones you think are most important, can you estimate a probability that they are real?
What’s the strongest historical/cultural counterexample to your theory of the obesity crisis?1
What do you think of “calories in calories out?” How consistent and controllable are calories out?
What are some different ways that people experience hunger, fullness, and satiety?2
What’s going on with non-allergy food intolerances? (Eg gluten, nightshades, etc.)
How temporary or permanent are allergies? What are some things you can do to prevent the development of allergies?
How temporary or permanent are non-allergy food intolerances? How might these be lessened or removed over time?
When people refer to “seed oils,” what’s going on, i.e., what property of seed oils’ chemistry or processing is important?3 What other foods have the same properties?
What’s going on with the people who do well on Ray Peat-esque diets? Carnivore? Raw veganism? The potato diet?4
What percentage of SIBO diagnoses do you think are real?5
In what situations is it not a good idea to “replenish your microbiome” with fermented food?
How much does paleo actually mimic ancestral diets? Whose ancestors, and when? Is this a good thing, or a fallacious appeal to tradition?
How much does the nervous system affect digestion—the manner and emotional context in which food is eaten, whether you expect it to feel good, whether it tastes good, whether you’re mentally prepared for the specific meal in front of you?
Do you think the existence of GLP-1s obviates this whole conversation? Why or why not?
These questions are very shaped by my own dietary journey. Someone with different problems would ask questions that stump me, and rightfully so. I’d love to hear in the comments if you have similar competence-testing questions.
Some fun ones from the Peater/polyunsaturated fat hater community: the Kitava (ultra-clean and low-PUFA diet, no increase in heart disease with the introduction of tobacco), modern Japan (low obesity high diabetes), modern Israel (why do these active people who eat vegetables have so much diabetes?!?1), Ancient Egypt (started getting sicker when they started mass-producing sesame oil). The key counterexample to their bullshit, of course, is that China has been eating lots of rapeseed oil since the Tang dynasty with no issues.
This question is super fun, because a lot of people aren’t aware that there is any way to experience hunger and fullness other than the way they personally experience it.
As someone who had a severe seed oil intolerance for years, I don’t consider “it’s all conspiracy theory nonsense” a serious answer. As someone who no longer has one, I don’t consider “seed oils are bad for everyone in the same way” a serious answer either.
Challenging the premise that these people are doing “well” long-term is a great answer. Provided, of course, that you understand that many of these people get extremely sick on the Standard American Diet and may not know of an alternative they can tolerate.
Gut microbiome stuff is both obviously super important, and so vague/fuzzy/unfalsifiable/hard-to-affect that it’s really hard to formulate good questions. This and the following one are the best I have come up with.