talia morgan

Shepard Tone Theory of Everything

The Falling Shepard Tone consists of a set of sine waves, separated by octaves, that slide downward in pitch together. As each sine wave descends, it grows louder, then softer until you can’t hear it at all.

If you’re like most listeners, your attention latches onto an individual falling sine wave. You perceive the sound as getting lower in pitch. But higher notes are always coming in, and the whole Shepard tone remains exactly as loud at each frequency as it has been all along. You experience the vertiginous sensation of falling forever while going nowhere.

I contend that everything is a Shepard tone.

Everywhere I go, I hear things are getting worse. Leftists decry late capitalism and “enshittification.” Liberals and centrists point to hollowing institutions and declining state capacity. Reactionaries have compared every decade to the Late Roman Empire since the Late Roman Empire.

Some claims of decline are dubious or dead wrong, but I’m sympathetic to many. In college, I TA’ed the advanced track of freshman physics for 3 years, before and after my alma mater dropped the SAT. Maybe my new pupils were less bright or worse-prepared, hard to say, but the attitude difference was unmistakeable. Students no longer felt obligated to try a problem even a little bit before asking me for a complete walkthrough. Several tenets of the social contract—standards mean something, you as a physics or engineering major should understand Maxwell’s Equations, your TA wants to help you learn—had evaporated into thin air.

If you fix your gaze on a single institution, you will be right to mourn its decline. It is sad that the courts are losing legitimacy, and parents get CPS calls for letting their kids walk to the park alone, and municipal transit services are forced to enter the slutwear business to stay afloat.

Never mind, I can’t pretend I hate this.

But even if you’re grieving something real, do you want to grieve forever?

In grad school, I spent most of my free time hanging out with the socialist academics who took me in after a breakup and a death in my family. Several nights a week, we played video games, sightread film scores, and kept the Thai restaurant downtown in business. It was fair to describe the prevailing friend group ideology as Disco Elysium Thought: the Revolution has failed and everything has collapsed, but a gentle breeze from nowhere fans the embers of hope, sort of, sometimes. I’m a resolute neolib, but I once got addicted to Ravel until I hit rock bottom, quit listening, and suffered withdrawal symptoms. My disposition fit right in.

I loved my friends to pieces and stay in touch with many, but the difference in our attitudes grew. I was the only one verbally jousting on Rationalist twitter or working other jobs to pay for a nicer apartment, so I was exposed to a constant influx of new information. While most of my friends’ idea of AI capabilities dates to the first release of ChatGPT, I kept playing with new models until they got scary. I found it hard to obsess over the poor quality of mainstream media when my favorite novel of this decade came out online for free. Eventually, I realized I was only in grad school because I’d given up on other vocations too soon. While the others stayed, I left.

I don’t know why my heart softened enough to notice signs of change in the world. (I can say for sure that you can open to possibility without feeling happy or optimistic.) Once I met him, my fiancé accelerated the process significantly, but something had clicked into place before. Maybe pessimism is just boring.

If there is any way to transmit this mindset shift, to draw the reader’s attention from one falling tone to the immovable fullness of the sound, it is the one thing I would really like to do.