talia morgan

The Balcony

By Vilhelm Hammershøi - http://www.um.dk/Publikationer/UM/Deutsch/DanischeThemen/BildendeKunst/html/chapter01.htm, http://isabelledescharbinieres.hautetfort.com/archive/2006/05/29/de-la-modestie-des-femmes.html, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=2679809

With my simple, firm, and expertly defended boundaries, I allow my colleagues to believe that I am a machine or apparition, or perhaps an angel. I never eat or drink in their presence, or even imply that I might eat or drink on occasion. When I relieve myself or head up to the rooftop for a cigarette, I excuse myself without providing a reason. (The nearest ladies’ room is all the way down on the fourth floor, so even the length of my absence clarifies nothing.) I make no references to coming from a family or engaging in romantic or sexual behavior. I am adept at carrying on lengthy and heady conversations while allowing no one to steer me into terra incognita, all the while slipping in unprofessionalisms—gossip; ill-advised political commentary; foul language, in both the vernacular and my quaint, colorful native tongue—just often enough to demonstrate that I’m no square.

Surely my colleagues have gathered that I am a human being, at least those whose theory of mind permits the existence of other intelligent life. That is fine, and beside the point. I simply see no reason to reveal what kind of human I am.

Gradually, I came to realize that the Fellow who joined us last October, Edgar Perlmutter, lived by similar or identical rules. He too remained in the seminar room peppering the speaker with questions while everyone else left for lunch, only slinking away when he thought no one was looking. He behaved as if highly caffeinated at all times, but I never saw him at the coffee machine. He was cordial to everyone, even warm to many. No one seemed to know quite where he came from before graduate school. Edgar might well have washed up on the rocks hundreds of feet beneath us, a duller, grimmer Aphrodite at Cythera.

The other reason I noticed Edgar at all is that he’s just my sort of man—dark-haired, blue-eyed, big and coarse in appearance, but careful and deft in behavior. After my husband’s death, though, I am generally content to observe men from a distance, even those who are not my professional colleagues. Since I did work with Edgar, it was even more important to maintain my privacy, and even easier to observe him—pacing up and down the halls, filling sheets of paper with schoolteacher-neat script, removing his jacket and rolling his sleeves up to help the janitor carry a broken armchair.

Several weeks ago, Edgar and I happened into our first real conversation, beyond the usual pleasantries. I’d just gotten out of an argument with our vituperative Dean about why I refuse to teach our most tedious course for non-majors for the fifth year in a row. I can hardly remember what I said, but I must have won, because the Dean eventually scurried away like the rat he is. It was late in the evening and I didn’t want to keep working, but I didn’t quite feel like getting on the train home either. I opened a window to the dark winter air, traversed the hall without incident, and found myself at the usual critical juncture.

The same number of stairs leads down to the bathroom or up to the top floor balcony. I usually let the needs of my body determine my path, but today my body needed nothing. My bladder was as dry as my hoarse, aching throat, and I didn’t feel like a smoke. Given this rare opportunity to exercise free will on something unrelated to my research, I chose to head up. Three or four people passed me on the way, disheveled undergraduates, gaunt old men, nobody you or I would know.

Through the balcony’s glass doors I saw a huge dark shape beyond the cast-iron railing. As I came outside I saw a man in an anonymous blue overcoat perched improbably on a ledge overhanging the alley below, staring down. I assumed, perhaps hastily—but imagine if I failed to intervene in time!—that he was about to jump, rushed outside onto the balcony, and called out to him. “Wait, don’t do it! At least talk to me first!”

My cries did more to startle the man than deter him. He flinched, and for a sickening instant, nearly fell off, but he caught himself on a curlicue of the railing just in time. As he turned around, I could see it was Edgar, trying to look appropriately serious but unable to keep a little bemusement from sneaking into his expression. He climbed back over the railing, dismounted more gracefully than I’d have expected, and came up to me.

“I’m sorry for giving you such a fright, Professor. I wasn’t trying to kill myself. I’ve already finished my PhD, why would I do it now? I just like to sit up here and look out, and I didn’t expect anyone to be up here at this hour.”

“It’s all right, Edgar,” I replied. “It’s none of my business whether you risk life and limb. I suppose all was well until I interrupted you.”

Though I demanded no explanation, Edgar kept talking.

“As implausible as it might seem, I happen to have no fear of death,” he said. “It doesn’t seem like I’m mad, or if I am, no one’s had the nerve to tell me. I’m just unusual in this one respect.”

Gears long rusted still began to turn in my brain, inexorably creaking into motion. I could repress hunger and thirst, sublimate sexual desire, but there was no use feigning indifference to this piece of information. In the least enthusiastic voice I could muster, I told Edgar his fearlessness must be a great blessing and that he seemed normal, to me, anyway.

“Really,” Edgar continued, “I’m no more likely to fall—at least, not without your help!—than I am from one of the little terraces around Morehouse Green. I might as well take in the view without anything in the way. There are no tall buildings and no sea where I come from, so I don’t take it for granted.”

I told Edgar I understood, and I did. If I could be at ease sitting there, in complete continuity with everything below—the bustle of people and cars in the street, the many-colored lights of a prosperous city, the cliffs and the dark water beyond—I think I would too. But I cannot be at ease. I imagine their bodies burnt and flayed and mangled, as so many of them will be in Hell. And I am reminded that I alone know this for a fact.

Joseph Wright of Derby, An Experiment on a Bird in the Air Pump (1768)

Perhaps I ought to explain a bit more about what I actually do than you’ll find in any breathless university press release. Among the better-funded and less impenetrable topics that make up the majority of my published research, I’ve taken a stab at the age-old question of what happens after we die. Unlike most other researchers in the field, I’m a committed empiricist, so much so that my professorship is in Applied Metaphysics. I refuse to write off one of our most fundamental mysteries as intractable and unfalsifiable, and I am not looking to die anytime soon. These formidable constraints have led me to some unusual methods. However, I attribute what little success I’ve had to my scrappy, resourceful approach.

Rather than attempting to travel to some underworld and return—a fool’s errand that has claimed many experimenters’ lives—or attempting to scry through the highest-bandwidth (and most heavily guarded) augural channels, I thought I might as well hijack existing pathways for short, cryptic messages which currently carry prophecy and revelations. I had to bring my entire life to bear on this project, from my education in electrical engineering and information theory to my late husband’s poetic genius. Since funding for such endeavors is nonexistent and few graduate students are inclined to work on them, I did the work alone on a nearly nonexistent budget, siphoning surplus resources from my more above-board projects.

After years of tinkering, I had a device that just might do the trick. I will not bore you with the technical details, merely paint a picture. The transmitter is a robust little sensor, something like a wristwatch, that can be strapped inside the arm of a dying man and stay in place through any thrashings of agony that might occur. The receiver punches holes in cards of paper to encode his message. The cards are small, closer in size to a standard index card than a typical punch card. This is fine, because prophetic channels are barely wide enough to accommodate a few lines of text.

Testing my device proved harder even than making it. There aren’t many places you can rely upon finding someone at the moment of death, and they are all as forbidding as you might expect. I was kindly offered access to a hospice ward by a colleague in the medical sciences, Dr. H___. The nurses always seemed to know, in their way, which patient was next. They liked me enough to beckon me over, perhaps because my experimental procedure livened things up. I only had to strap my device to each tortured geriatric’s ropy wrist, and wait, and wait, and wait.

The messages, however, left something to be desired. A fairly representative sampling:

“What’s this? Can I t”

“Ffrrrrrrrhhh,34.;”

“g oodbyw mary i miss ye odl girl”

The sender of the last message really did have—not a wife named Mary, as I had guessed, but a basset hound named Mary Lou, who went on to outlive him by four months. Nothing rock-solid yet, but it gave me enough hope not to scrap the project completely.

On to a population of sounder mind. I could think of one, but it was even more unsavory than the sour-smelling hospital ward, and furthermore, fiendishly difficult to access. Four hours’ drive southwest, in the fetid swampland, there is a maximum security prison, qualified to administer capital punishment, with a few tenuous connections to my institution.

The university proudly advertises its do-gooders who help the inmates put on a Shakespeare play each year. It is quieter about the number of psychological experiments run on incarcerated subjects—yes, crueler experiments than showing Love’s Labour’s Lost to an illiterate, murderous bumpkin barred from exiting the building. When I proposed my experiments to the warden, she seemed rather disappointed that my work involved no behavioral conditioning, electric shocks, corrosive substances, or the like. Luckily, my pet project’s complete lack of institutional oversight proved tantalizing enough. I was in.

Since the electric chair would damage my precious invention, I was granted access to the condemned of an old-fashioned enough bent to request the guillotine—or everyone, when the power went out or the chair threw off too many sparks. I am usually fairly cold and indifferent, but here, I couldn’t be. I really don’t want to reproduce the convicts’ words here—they’re in my papers somewhere, if you really must read. Vistas of the deepest hells, fiery recriminations against the guards and the state, sorrow for their victims or pleas in vain that they were innocent, and worst of all, the bursts of wordless agony, whose violent force made the hole-punch shake and sputter.

Still, even in the abattoir, I made progress. Over my many visits I formed something of a friendship with N___, a murderess barely out of her teens whose politeness and penitence may well have been genuine. When her day finally came, she agreed to write down a number and seal it in a secret envelope, to be opened after her death. The number in her envelope matched the message still clicking into the punch card, taking my breath away:

“EIGHT TRUMPETS

EIGHT OIL-BLACK RIVERS

EIGHT WOUNDS CLEAVE ME”

If I could find more subjects as articulate as N___, covering the full spectrum from good to ordinary to evil, and show up right when they were about to die, then I would have it made. Anyone could take a good hard look at their life and know exactly what to expect. Finding a large enough sample size to placate the scientific community would be nigh impossible, which is part of why my work on afterlives still remains unpublished. I told myself I didn’t even know where to find one suitable subject. But of course, I did.

Rembrandt, The Archangel Raphael Leaving the Family of Tobias (1637)

All along, my husband had been watching the proceedings with great interest, and not only because he hoped for my success. Felipe was undeniably eccentric, if not in quite the way everyone else thinks. He published under a dizzying array of pseudonyms and slowly drip-fed them to me. It wasn’t because he wanted to keep secrets from me; he merely forgot about any manuscript he wasn’t actively working on. Until I took the liberty to sift through his filing cabinets, I thought of his oeuvre as Arturo de Luca’s few volumes of poetry, Diane Edelweiss’s detective novels, Lewis Lewisham and Ivan Ivanovich’s satires (these, at least, readers should have been be able to correlate), and whatever brought in the other half of the royalty checks.

Still, even before we married, my husband supplied me with enough points to draw a line. All his works, excepting the ghost-written nonfiction volumes on howler monkey morphology, revealed a rather anodyne preoccupation with cruel and powerful women. (Felipe overestimated my cruelty at first, since I gave a scathing critique of one of his noms de plume at a Christmas party in the islands, but it hardly mattered once we got to know each other.) Far more interesting—to me, anyway—was a recurring theme of romantic murder. He kept illustrations of praying mantises and anglerfish pinned above his desk. He followed my afterlife experiments with obvious interest. Neither of us dared to nominate him as a test subject until, when I was trying to replace N___, my hair began to fall out from stress.

We did a great deal of research into how he could arrange his death so I would not be held legally responsible, without draining the moment of intimacy or scientific potential. My attorney advises me not to share the specifics, and in any case it would be crude. Yes, it was everything I hoped for, and all the same, I regretted it terribly. For days I’d arrive at the office, deliver a barely adequate lecture, achieve nothing, and go home to wallow in place on my armchair until my eyelids flickered shut. Felipe’s final resting place, as he relayed it to me, was a beige void. I could hardly say the world of the living was any better.

At some point I had to pull myself together. I started to show my face in colloquium again, leaf through Felipe’s manuscripts, walk along the bluffs on weekends. It took a year to begin writing a monograph in earnest. By the time Edgar materialized, I had typed up sixty or seventy pages, and I sat in my office to write almost as often as I sat down to feign productivity. I could certainly find an audience for the results I had, but more data would strengthen my research considerably…

Meeting Edgar on the rooftop alleviated much of my usual discomfort with the human race, and a pleasant tension had taken its place. I contrived to attend any talk I knew he would. He fetched more pens and paperclips than he could possibly need from the supply closet near my office, always stopping in for a chat. Neither of us would eat or drink in the other’s presence, or allude to a life outside work, which only made our friendship feel more like an affair. All the better, I thought. If he believes my desire is some great secret he’s unearthed, he won’t realize how far it is from my first priority.

I continued to gather information on Edgar Perlmutter, probing his suitability as a subject for afterlife research. I could not believe my luck when I found out he had no living relatives. As it happened, Edgar had studied informatics in his youth and jumped ship during metaphysics’ computational renaissance, like I did. The only reason I’d never seen his name on a paper, I gathered, was that his subsequent research was of a sensitive nature and conducted during the War. He was not at liberty to tell me whether he had secured the Army’s communications, decoded intelligence for a five-letter agency, or something else. But, like many men of espionage, he could not stop himself from recounting his youth full of daring and intrigue to a lady. Far from rotting in a bunker during his service, he had more bullet-holes in his body than I had fillings in my teeth.

Really, Edgar’s camouflage was excellent. I hardly blame myself for not realizing what was going on. His only slip was that he could not be bothered to spend as long in transit as you or I might. He taught a recitation in the Lundgren building, over a mile away from Applied Metaphysics, for example, but I’d often find him in his office a few minutes after it ended. I should have known he would never let a class out early.

At last I worked up the courage to ask Edgar to die for me. He gave no indication that he wanted to be murdered, as Felipe had, but he had no particular attachment to life, and he seemed to be attached to me. That would have to be good enough. I invited him on a walk in the lilac garden—private enough to speak openly, since the branches were still bare—and, before nerves could overtake me, laid out the true nature of my research program and his possible role in it.

As I spoke, Edgar’s body stiffened and contorted. He emerged with a new posture and expression, no longer looking like himself at all. A taller, stiffer man loomed over me, eyes pale and empty as a goat’s.

“It’s funny that you mention your afterlife research,” Edgar said, in a tinny voice I’d never heard before. “I am actually here at this university under slightly false pretenses to ask you to pause this line of investigation.”

“I’m a security administrator from the Human Afterlife Program,” he continued. “We take unauthorized communication extremely seriously. If information is allowed to exit the confines of Heaven and Hell, human minds preserved within undergo quality degradation. Your experiments compromise the eternity of the soul.”

I took time to consider my words before speaking.

“I’m sorry for any souls I have harmed,” I said. “I do believe humanity deserves to know what will happen in the world beyond. I won’t gather new data—I am hardly able to, anyway—but I intend to publish the results I have. To be frank, I don’t see how you can stop me from releasing my monograph. I have always worked within the bounds of the law, and I’ve never expected to make it to Heaven.”

Edgar let out a puff of air that was not quite a laugh. “Whether or not your creative justification for murder holds up in court, you’ve been using government research grants for unauthorized purposes. If I placed a call to the National Bureau of Soteriology, you’d never get funding for anything again. Your academic life will be over.”

He had me there.

“By the way, I can bypass thaumaturgic seals to send messages to your receiver even if the transmitter is powered off. If anyone gets some funny ideas about picking your research program back up, I will send them a personal cease and desist.”

“All right. I understand. I’d just like to be sure this isn’t some kind of sick joke,” I said. “Perform a miracle to prove you are not mortal. If you do, I will stop.”

Edgar shrank back to his usual proportions, a great man pretending to be small.

“Happy to oblige,” he said in his old voice. “Come to the balcony with me and wait until the crowds in the street disperse.”

“That won’t be until after midnight,” I observed.

If I was not mistaken, he nearly smiled. “Do you really have anything better to do?”

So Edgar and I sat on a bench on the balcony, so close together that I felt the absence of warmth from his body. I had thought about fetching the decanter of brandy from my office, but I could not face the embarrassment of being seen to consume fluid sober, nor the greater shame of taking a swig in secret. My throat grew hoarse and dry.

I wanted to start a conversation, but my tongue faltered. Any question I wanted Edgar to answer would be an unconscionable security leak, and I had nothing to contribute. How could the being next to me possibly care about department gossip or modernist poetry or my futile human life? Could I tell an angel anything he did not already know?

At last the street thinned out, empty but for the occasional pair of headlights or stumbling drunkard. Edgar stood up abruptly. “I’ll see you again, Delphine,” he said, as he walked to the edge of the balcony. In one effortless motion, he scaled the cast-iron railing and threw himself down headfirst.

Eight floors below, Edgar landed intact and seemingly unharmed, dusting off his overcoat. He turned a corner into the bright main street and disappeared beneath the awning of the train station.

I returned to my office and opened the one locking drawer in my desk, where I keep both my brandy and what remains of the afterlife device. As I picked up the crystal decanter, I caught a whiff of smoke, and I noticed that the receiver’s output tray was not—as I left it—empty.

A punch card lay waiting, studded with burn-holes. An ember appeared on the paper and sputtered out again, leaving a new hole ringed with soot. I began to feel giddy as a schoolgirl. I hadn’t dared to hope he would write.