The Last Castrato
Many of you have already heard of the castrati, Italian singers castrated before puberty to preserve a high, boyish voice. Perhaps you were lucky, and came across them in music history class or Astral Codex Ten book reviews. Perhaps you were not so lucky, and you discovered them while browsing gore hentai. At least in my education, castrati were presented as a lost curiosity from the 15th to 18th century, whose voices we can only imagine. However, this is hardly the case—Alessandro Moreschi, opera singer and head soprano of the Sistine Chapel Choir, left us with a remarkable recording of a sound otherwise gone forever.
Listen to it before scrolling further, if you’ll indulge me. I don’t want to color your impression.
Perhaps fittingly for a liminal, androgynous figure, the castrato voice serves as a mirror. A sweep of historical remarks on the castrato’s sound, and YouTube comments on this video, reveals that listeners hear whatever they want to hear.
Personally, I suspect the commenters who hear Moreschi’s voice as creepy or scary are simply projecting the dark history of the castrati into the sound of his voice. That, or they aren’t accustomed to high classical voices or record scratches and pops—people say the same about old recordings of sopranos and falsettists all the time. I know a creepy voice when I hear one, and Moreschi’s doesn’t register on the same scale.
On the other hand, when historical and modern commentators ascribe exceptional purity, flexibility, or any sort of prettiness to his voice, I can’t say I hear that either. Easy for me to say, perhaps, as a modern listener with the privilege of hearing natural countertenors whenever I want. Moreschi was also in his early 40s by the time recordings were made, apparently past his prime. (There’s a deep tragedy to that, too. The castrato voice must decline faster than any other voice type, despite the great human cost paid to preserve a youthful sound.)
I’ll tell you what I hear, though I am projecting as much as anyone else. I attribute nearly all of Moreschi’s unique sound to his ability to sing high notes in chest voice, beyond where an ordinary adult male or female would have to switch to head voice or falsetto. He’s able to sing with a warmer, stronger, and fuller-bodied register in a dizzyingly high range. While a young boy could do the same, he wouldn’t be backed by the power of adult-sized lungs. The handful of intersex or otherwise physically gifted adults who can sing in high chest voice, without enduring surgery before anesthetics and antibiotics, aren’t missing much.
What Moreschi has that contemporary singers do not is his life experience. Neither the brutality of castration; nor the social context that produced, trained, and celebrated castrati; nor the innocent faith of a rural Roman Catholic who lived before the 20th-century decline in religion can be recreated. (Hearing this recording, I believe he sings to the Virgin Mary fully expecting her to listen.) It all comes across so clearly in Moreschi’s plaintive voice.
The physical and emotional experience of being a child didn’t work for me. I always wanted out. It was a huge relief to hit 15 or 16 and no longer feel like my will was being painfully forced out of my inadequate body, like stale play-doh through the thinnest spaghetti extruder. Moreschi’s voice captures that exact quality so acutely, and it moves me because I can’t fathom being stuck like that forever. I’m given to understand some people remember their childhoods fondly. But surely some castrati felt like I did to begin with, and others came to feel that way when childhood never ended.
Even if I were more of a deranged art-maximizer than I already am and threw all concern for human life out the window, I see no reason to recreate the exact circumstances of Moreschi’s career. Whatever’s there, it seems like he covered it, and I’m not sure you can hear a difference from singers who lived through any other great injustice. Still, though, take a few minutes to share in his sorrows and joys.