talia morgan

Shop Like You're Slaying the Spire

A lot of us want to lead simpler lives with less waste and excess. Less cognitive overhead spent buying things and putting them away and getting rid of them. An emptier home that feels spacious and roomy. Fewer choices about things that don’t matter, so you can approach your relationships, creative projects, and business decisions feeling serene and full of energy. If you’re like me, you feel amazing living out of a medium-sized checked bag for a couple months and disgusted when you get back home and there are THINGS EVERYWHERE. This has unsettling implications for the rest of your life.

Aside from our lady Marie Kondo, most resources about how to do this suck. The better ones are merely bad for specific people. Frugality resources assume you have a lot of free time you can trade for money by comparison shopping and pickling vegetables. “Rich people minimalism” assumes you might as well throw shit out, because high quality replacements will surely(!) still be made, and you’ll surely(!) be able to find and afford them. Both of these assumptions are, to put it mildly, out of touch.

The worse resources are fond of preachy, moralistic environmentalism and shaming people for inconsequential personal choices. If you are one of the blessed, beautiful souls who live to do good: your views on global warming and pollution may vary, but the truth is that individual consumer choices are a drop in the bucket compared to large-scale political, economic, and technological factors. Most “eco-friendly” personal habits are washed away by taking one extra plane flight a year, let alone anything systemic. If they’re difficult or unpleasant to maintain, they trade off against developing new technology and enacting social change. If you’re not one of those beautiful souls: why do you care what other people think? If someone complains about the paper plates at your dinner party, you don’t need to invite them back.

Here is a new, class-agnostic, scolding-free principle for acquiring stuff.

Like most good ideas, it originated in the deckbuilding game community. In his seminal video essay “Heuristics, Archetypes, and Jobs,” Youtuber Jorbs explains two different philosophies for decision-making in the game Slay the Spire: archetypes and jobs.

In each run of Slay the Spire, whether the original game or the sequel, you start with a small deck of generic cards. Between fights with enemies, you face a series of opportunities to acquire new cards and, much less often, get rid of old ones that aren’t pulling their weight. Both combat and resource rewards are randomized, with cards getting slightly better and fights becoming much harder over the course of the game. If you have too many cards in your deck, you become less likely to draw your best cards—much like how a closet full of clothes you don’t really like makes you waste time searching for the ones you actually wear.

Shops are full of exciting items. Often, the best value for your money is paying to throw a card away.

Over time, most people gravitate toward particular archetypes or builds. For instance, you might seek to design a deck around dealing poison damage. The problem with the archetype approach is that it requires betting you will find particular cards or other resources later. Maybe the game won’t give you the best poison cards in a given run. By waiting for them, you pass up good opportunities to deal damage and block enemy attacks in different ways. In the worst-case scenario, you might even take an ability that empowers poison and never come across the base poison-inflicting cards you need for it to work. Similarly, in real life, people often acquire objects—craft and hobby tools being the worst offenders—that are of no use without other objects, or without the most precious resource of all, an uninterrupted block of time.

A better strategy is to divide the game into a series of fine-grained jobs that your cards need to accomplish at different stages of the game: blocking a 45-damage attack, taking down a boss that inflicts status effects, helping you draw the specific card you want, and so on. You also know that later-game challenges will be more difficult, and you need solutions that scale—ways to deal or block increasing amounts of damage with the same cards. When you have a list of top-priority jobs in your head, it becomes much easier to evaluate any given opportunity. Does a card solve an immediate or upcoming problem for you, while also having enough scaling potential to meet later challenges? If so, grab it. If not, let it go.

The artistry of the game lies in choosing between different urgent needs and crafting resourceful combos and synergies when there are no simple solutions to your problems. Adopting a jobs-based philosophy will quickly de-bloat your decks while you learn the harder stuff.

Similarly, when making decisions about buying or scavenging new objects, you can ask whether a) they solve an urgent problem, b) nothing you already own can solve the same problem, and c) they scale to tougher challenges by being durable enough to last and fitting into your space. It’s important to make and maintain a running list of problems/jobs BEFORE you go shopping to avoid fooling yourself. If an item will solve a problem you might have in a few months, why not wait a few months and see if that problem even comes up?1 You may or may not be able to get the exact same thing. But unless you’re overwintering in Antarctica, you will certainly go somewhere you can find a new solution.

Using this approach successfully requires an expansive notion of jobs. It’s okay if an item’s job is to look nice or make you happy. You can buy a rare, special item proactively, but only if it will do a real job well and with style. (Often, a quick eBay search, or asking your LLM of choice to identify a photo, will show you that it isn’t rare or special after all.)

“Stocking up” on anything more specialized than paper towels is a sucker’s game. Your excitement about using a new purchase is a martingale at best. If you can’t figure out how to put a fancy spice in dinner today or tomorrow, it is very likely you will never use it at all.

Here’s an example of the jobs heuristic: I was thinking about getting cute white sneakers to wear with dresses this summer. I thought about what they would actually accomplish and realized there is no situation in which I can’t just wear regular tennis shoes or ballet flats (work), comfy sandals (going out, if I need to walk a lot), or heels (going out, if I don’t). Immediately the desire vanished, and my life was simpler. It’s that easy.

1

The main exception is that seasonal clothes can really be cheaper in off-season sales. I think it’s usually not worth planning ahead. 6 months is a long time! You might move to another climate, gain or lose enough weight to need a different size, or receive a gift or a thrift-store find that supersedes whatever you were going to buy.