the gist of the ayurvedic world model
this is a composite of notes from conversations with Jessica Vellela and the book Prakriti: Your Ayurvedic Constitution. see Ayurveda FAQ for discussion of why I got into this. compared to studying the classics, this post is like bodybuilder bro-science—cobbled together, likely wrong in important ways, but handy for practical use.
good things
agni, lit. fire: digestive capacity
the power to process/transform food, environment, and experience
strengthening, stabilizing, and in some cases taming the excesses of agni is the central goal of ayurveda. it keeps everything else running smoothly
bala: flesh
power, strength, resilience. includes both muscle and healthy/non-waste fat.
you need reserves of this to tolerate any kind of cleansing or intense treatment (not to mention exercise or, like, getting out of bed)
ahamkara: capacity to distinguish between you and not-you
encompasses both immune system and psychological self-other boundary. all diseases are in some way a weakness of ahamkara and all deaths a failure
built in hint system
in the more spiritual presentations, distinctly female, blurring of mother/child/lover/goddess roles.
you might ask, how does she feel different as an archetype/entity if youre not a horny straight man. honestly not very? personally I think the thoth tarot’s Princess of Earth is a spot-on depiction, as are some catholic women’s descriptions of their relationship with the Virgin Mary.
if you’ve failed to protect her badly enough, even by no fault of your own, it is hard to rebuild trust. i have a sense i will be working on it my whole life.
bad(?) things
doshas
doshas are the mediation of elemental balances within the body.
they have a tendency to go out of whack. name in sanskrit reflects this; essentially means “thing that can become corrupted.”
vata: air (really wind) and space need each other. wind needs empty space to move through or it will rip the body apart. empty space without air/wind becomes stagnant.
high vata -> too windy, low vata -> too spacious/stagnant
pitta: forcing water and fire to get along, without fire boiling off water or water quenching fire. fire here often a metaphor for acidity, particularly stomach acid, or anything else that follows a cooking process
high pitta -> fire winning, low pitta -> water winning
kapha: suspending or dissolving solids in water (emulsions, mucilage, etc). forcing water and earth to mix.
high kapha -> too much slime, low kapha -> too much separation
doshas in balance = this thing is successfully maintaining equilibrium between two forces (uniting them or resolving a conflict)
i have a theory that the direction of these dosha axes is chosen to make the high side the one you get to by overdoing life: overeating or eating overly complex and varied foods, overworking or over-traveling and undersleeping, overusing drugs, etc.
pitta is distinguished by being heating (the other two are cooling), vata by being drying (the other two are oily/moistening), and kapha by being heavy (the other two are light).
as far as i can tell the way these terms are used are identical to traditional chinese medicine and european herbalism. it would be kinda concerning if it wasn’t
sometimes people disagree about heating and cooling because a food will heat and cool at different stages of digestion or in different ways (eg lemons, cooked onions, honey).
this stuff can get so pedantic
pitta is related to agni but not the same thing. pitta constitution people tend to have more digestive power, but in the seasons where pitta dosha spikes, agni runs low. I don’t really understand why this is the case tbh.
in the same sense, kapha is related to bala but not the same thing, and they have different seasonal timing.
stop asking if they are good or bad!! its complicated okay!!!
there’s a sense in which the purity of God is better than any kind of traits
imagine being described by adjectives. yuck!
in the more pragmatic/biomedical version of ayurveda, you need a bit of every dosha to make the body run. there are healthy and toxic forms of each, and something that would otherwise be healthy can become unhealthy in excess
caraka samhita, the main internal medicine text, is pretty evenhanded on the doshas.
sushruta samhita, the main surgical text, is more negative on the doshas. how’d you like to be described as thieving yet slow to accumulate gold and jewels?
ama: waste
anything the body does not successfully incorporate or eliminate.
in terms of other concepts: substances your agni is not strong enough to digest; foreign invaders your ahamkara was too weak to keep out or did not recognize as such.
similar to how western hippies talk about toxins, but not necessarily poisonous in origin--most of it is just food you weren’t hungry for or your body does not absorb correctly.
important note most of what western hippies recommend for “detoxing,” like drinking massive amounts of apple cider vinegar, will in fact create more waste than it eliminates.
like all ayurvedic definitions this is a practical one: it points to a large cluster of different biological or chemical structures/compounds united mostly by the fact that they shouldn’t be there. I think it is more difficult than useful to try to list every reductionist description.
an important one that comes up a lot is biofilms.
anything weird or (unusually) foul-smelling about the body’s excretions is a sign of ama making an exit.
you have a doshic baseline constitution (prakriti). i think this single concept is responsible for more misconceptions than any of the others.
what exactly does baseline mean? a lot of less rigorous resources say “the state you were in as a child.” but if you were born with severe medical problems, you’ve never actually been in your prakriti.
Seems like a pretty big oversight if you’re trying to treat, yknow, sick people.
When does the timer start? Are prenatal events included in your prakriti? I don’t actually know, I would guess the answer depends on which. it would be cruel to say something like fetal alcohol syndrome is inherent to a person, rather than imposed on them by outside forces. but it is also true that it’s an inescapable part of their lot in life.
adding to this confusion, prakriti can be used to refer to multiple different levels of detail/resolution.
the lowest level is a doshic “type” that people treat as sort of a hogwarts house personality quiz thing. your most prominent dosha, then your second if it’s also fairly prominent.
why use the lower resolution method at all if you have higher resolution info? there are a couple reasons why it’s still useful
one is that if you’re the kind of person who is really tuned into personality/physiognomy/essence/gestalt kind of stuff, once you are familiar with the system people’s prakritis start hitting you like a sack of bricks. obviously you shouldn’t start dispensing unsolicited medical advice, but you might as well learn how to pronounce “elephant” if there’s one in the room.
the other is that low-resolution prakritis capture something about what your parents were like at the time of your conception, and this can be interesting to ponder.
the second level of resolution is to look at the doshic baseline of different organs and systems in your body, as well as ayurveda’s other lists of categories (rajas/tamas/sattva, which describe different mental states; the six flavors which correspond both to tastes and to a set of bodily and psychological processes)
this is the minimum level that a competent ayurvedic practitioner is thinking about your body. the main thing they are working with is herbs or formulations that selectively affect specific organ systems and body parts, so you can treat one issue without messing the entire body up worse.
the third level is that + individualized qualitative detail. this includes both particular genes/alleles and holistic judgements/observations like “you have a cross-organ-system tendency to form tumors/masses” (rip)
The way Jess and Robert Svoboda use the term, in practice, seems to be “the state a person with your genes/parentage/prenatal-and-conception-situation would be in, if they led a chill life and their metabolism outpaced whatever toxins they took in”
some people’s prakritis are pretty rough, eg anyone with a genetic disorder. some people naturally more balanced and some people less balanced.
life aint fair kid
seasonal and age variations are also part of your “default” along with prakriti
it is possible to become better than your prakriti in a few different ways, but they are kind of narrowly scoped
one is to take formulations (or even just herbal teas) that round off the harsher edges of your experience and combat seasonal dosha variation. in this sense you can improve on the state of nature.
the other (per Svoboda) is to resolve ancestral traumas and forgive your parents, and thus purify yourself of the doshas
this is pretty woo even compared to the rest of ayurveda but i think there is something to it
i think he probably means purifying yourself of dosha imbalance not doshas, but it would be really funny if you become enlightened, cease to produce stomach acid, and die.
here are some myths about prakriti
most bad ayurvedic resources recommend eating for your prakriti in a one-dimensional way. this will probably beat the standard amercian diet like every other restricted diet, but diseases and even seasonal variation can swamp your prakriti. if you are suffering enough to put in the effort, you are likely far removed from baseline and maybe have all 3 doshas in excess.
“stay away from extreme, incompatible, and complicated foods” is a safer first pass recommendation than eating for your prakriti.
over-focus on body composition, rather than things that are actually permanent like bone structure and facial features.
it is true that kaphas often gain weight easily and vatas often struggle to put it on, but since obesity and anorexia became epidemics, bodyfat percentage has become less meaningful. it’s much more useful to look at someone’s skeleton, which remains true to type unless you’re Clavicular. the real reason this comes up is because a lot of turmeric blogger ayurveda is one big mid 2000s weight loss aid scam, and you can sell a lot of...artisanal turmeric? by convincing people you can save them from their destiny.
you also have a current state, called vikruti. assessing vikruti is hard, but conceptually it is much more intuitive. there are 2 levels of vikruti that are important:
detailed: what doshas are in what organ systems, what longer term diseases or processes are going on, throw all the western medicine diagnostic info in here too
“today’s vibe”
what doshas are free-floating in your bloodstream, basically. with experience of what excess feels like and some practice, you can identify this instantly from mood, the feeling of your muscles, digestion, and sleep cycle
this level is useful because it translates the most directly into how you should eat/exercise. if you’re in kapha excess from drinking too much chocolate milk yesterday, it’s going to have to leave before anything deeper or more chronic can exit your body.
for the most part anything that stands out is bad, but I have glimpses, with increasing frequency, of the good side of the doshas. these are the experiences the phrases fired up or light as air or grounded are meant to capture.
that’s all for now!