talia morgan

Stop Saying the T-word

Sometimes I daydream about banning the word trauma. Fortunately for the world, I have neither a genie to grant me wishes, nor a candidate replacement.

Here is a very, very incomplete list of things people might mean when they say “trauma.”

  1. Post-traumatic stress disorder

A fear response to a disturbing event, characterized by a fight-or-flight response, nightmares, flashbacks, and attempts to avoid reminders of the traumatic event. PTSD is a specific diagnosis recognized by two different medical classification systems, the DSM and ICD.

  1. Complex post-traumatic stress disorder

A response to a repeated, inescapable series of disturbing events, often during childhood. Characterized by similar symptoms to PTSD, plus some new ones: deep-seated shame or guilt; extreme emotions or numbness and dissociation; and difficulty forming or maintaining interpersonal relationships. These symptoms must cause significant life impairment.

C-PTSD is also a specific diagnosis (recognized by the ICD, not the DSM), and its criteria are in fact stricter than PTSD. If you are generally holding it together, and no one would ever mistake you for someone with borderline personality disorder, a reputable shrink will not diagnose you with C-PTSD—even if you experienced childhood abuse that still causes life-ruining anguish.1

A lot of people have most of the symptoms of C-PTSD, but mild enough to mostly hold down jobs and relationships. There are also a lot of abuse survivors whose fear remains subconscious, manifesting as stress-triggered diseases. Tiktok therapists will happily slap the C-PTSD label on them, but, like any fixed identity, it quickly goes from empowering to limiting.

I prefer to talk about this toned-down C-PTSD as a mechanistic process, rather than an intrinsic identity people have:

  1. Stored tension patterns

When people experience overpowering emotions that they cannot fully express or process, these get stuck and lead to rigidity: muscle tension, stiff and jerky movements, looping thoughts and anxious rumination. This physical rigidity is accompanied by various forms of mental limitation: the inability to replay certain memories in detail, express emotions you’ve repressed too much before, stand up for yourself, or pay attention to your senses, among others.

Meditators talk about this tension a lot because it shows up very crisply if you meditate. The best two descriptions of this phenomenon I’m aware of originate from meditation communities and name it “gnar” and “trauma smells.” Unfortunately, these names are even worse than “trauma.” Nobody is going to use those ugly names (except me, right now.)

These stored tension patterns are extremely common and not necessarily severe. Once you know what the facial tension patterns look like, you’ll see them on half the people in the grocery store. High-functioning and high-achieving people often have this; many people become high-achieving by exceptional repression and self-control.

Some can ignore the tension; for others it causes extreme, intolerable pain that needs to be treated. I tend to think the level of suffering has almost nothing to do with the severity of the inciting incidents. When people identify as traumatized from mild bullying or their parents’ divorce, it’s (usually) not “attention seeking.” They are usually trying to describe experiences of this nature, but they don’t have access to sophisticated terminology or a less intense or politically loaded word. So trauma it is.


As much as the T-word has started to grate on me, the above definitions of “trauma” at least make sense. They are all pathological, in the sense that one doesn’t have to be that way. It’s possible to endure a terrifying event and not get stuck in your emotional response.

And, even though the surface presentations are very different, they share an underlying mechanism and path to healing. I’ve experienced this firsthand. After being sexually assaulted in college, I developed a very textbook form of PTSD. After a few years, and especially after moving to another state, I stopped having flashbacks and no longer felt like the perpetrator was around every corner. The memory of my assault felt like any other. But I still felt tense, rigid, and trapped.

When I started to poke at the events of my early childhood, in therapy and on psychedelic trips, much of the tension started to relax. You’ll have to take my word for it, but the process, the sensations, were the same. On a much smaller scale, they are even the same for accepting a nasty comment or losing a competition. There’s a vast spectrum of different ways of being stuck in the past.

Unfortunately, people also use the word trauma in ways that are fucking stupid.

  1. A person responding rationally or slightly-more-than-rationally to their dangerous living situation

This isn’t pathological and there’s no reason to believe this person is stuck yet. It could turn into capital-T trauma later, but why assume one way or the other?

  1. Fear, anger, or grief about something that happened 5 days ago

Likewise, there’s nothing pathological going on here and this usage is dismissive of people’s capacity to heal. A few years ago, I had an elevated fight-or-flight response after a dental surgery where the anesthetic wore off. There was nothing emotionally or interpersonally loaded about the event; it just hurt a lot. A snapshot of my brain chemistry would probably be similar to the days after I was assaulted. But within a week I was able to fully replay the event in my head without fear or avoidance. Calling this trauma stretches the definition beyond any usefulness.

  1. Traumatic, as an adjective, to describe a type of event

The same experience might cause minor upset for some people and lifelong disability for others. It all depends on context: innate predisposition, ability to release muscle tension and stored emotions, and social support or isolation, among many other factors.

  1. The absence of feelings or beliefs you believe someone should have in response to a certain situation

This is a bit of a cheap shot, but I see a lot of discussions of trauma that are downright manipulative. It is true that people can respond to traumatic events with dissociation, denial or even complete loss of memory. It’s also true that sometimes, people miss the sinister implications of an event, and their emotional reaction is delayed. But it is also possible…that the event just wasn’t a big deal. It is not doing someone a favor to tell them they should be feeling worse, or even imply it with an unduly concerned tone of voice. If you want to leave space for someone to sort out their feelings, just ask how they’re doing, rather than assuming the answer.


What the stupid uses share in common is an implication that bad feelings are a mental illness: a psychological wound that requires active treatment rather than going away on its own. Most people don’t develop PTSD after experiencing horrific events. Even if they did, I do not want to be a pessimist about human resilience. How can people recover from tragedy if the expectation of long-term suffering is baked into the language?

1

This is not to say you can’t receive trauma therapy! You absolutely can, and I highly recommend trying it if you can find a good therapist. But your insurance papers will probably say you have “adjustment disorder.”