talia morgan

Noble Suffering in Nordic LARP

from Hinterland, 2015

I’ve been obsessively reading about Nordic LARPs: a genre of rules-light, psychologically-rich, high-production-value live action roleplaying games.

Ostensibly, this is research, for a game I’m (ostensibly) writing. Really, it’s that the best game narratives feel like gossip. LARPs are an infinite wellspring of situations and people to drop into them, social experiments no IRB would approve.

The most interesting games demand a sacrifice from their players.1 For happier games, it’s mere effort or inconvenience; bleak settings are paired with method-acted oppression, cold, and hunger. An American offshoot I’ve played in, Fielding’s Hollow, is explicitly and exquisitely designed around “suffering beautifully.” I’ve been hooked on sacrifice in games since I played Seeking Mr. Eaten’s Name, immolating 7 realtime months grinding and gambling for the opportunity to permanently kill my character for a few paragraphs of lore. It was electric. Nothing I’ve done in real life has come close.

So I don’t really know how far I’d go, how much cold and hunger and oppression I’d sign up for. The game Hinterland2, set in a plague-ridden Sweden under Russian invasion, strictly limited food and blankets and encouraged players to steal each other’s supplies, normally a taboo in even the darkest games. All weapons, from knives and clubs to rusty pitchforks, were real. They could only be used for intimidation—likely all that would be needed in real life. NPC raiders showed up with guard dogs to terrorize the players—who were lucky that plague infection were represented by salt pills hidden among sugar pills rather than envelopes of diegetic anthrax.

The game doesn’t seem to be running now or even have an active website. Still, reading about Hinterland triggers a febrile rush of FOMO, largely because it is actively against my best interests. Some people wanted to play to Understand the Refugee Experience, and I’m sure it helped, but that strikes me as a thin excuse. There are other high octane LARPs that have a lot going for them. Of course I’m curious to compare Libertines, a moderately censored 120 Days of Sodom3, to my experience with high protocol BDSM parties. Obviously I want to have a blast on the Chicago-to-LA band tour that plays gigs for real audiences who don’t know that it’s a LARP.4 Hinterland has nothing going for it but intensity, and that is the draw—just thinking about it brings the courageous and little-bitch parts of the soul into sharp relief.

Snapphaneland

It is strange to see people describe a part of my life as an exotic, “immersive” LARP experience.

In Christianity is an Immersion Closet5, one woman describes her experience as an in-character kitchen volunteer in the historical LARP Snapphaneland. She played a pious farm maid caught between a Swedish occupying force and the snapphanar, resistance fighters from the Swedish-Danish border. She spent long days chopping vegetables and tending the fire in the (real) kitchen, interspersed with (presumably not real) wartime rape and the destruction of her home. Whether other characters interacted with her or she worked alone, her thoughts were increasingly consumed by Heaven.6

While the author does not mention her own religious beliefs, she makes it sound like religion is a novel experience for her. Even though my beliefs and practice hardly resemble 1700s Protestantism either, I feel pretty weird about this.

Enduring suffering by focusing on God’s love is an everyday, almost unremarkable part of my life. So is withdrawing from certain worldly pleasures, though for different reasons. Most attempts to depict or simulate mysticism from the outside get these experiences wrong, but it seems to me like the author glimpsed something real. In these states bliss and pain are often happening, but they’re less important than clarity and subtle perception. Sin isn’t an arbitrary list of actions to avoid, but something you know in every bone of your body will cause more trouble than it’s worth.

The distancing tone of her description seems…bad for people figuring their own stuff out. While no one else is ultimately responsible for my years of affliction, it would have been nice if my surrounding culture presented faith—real faith, not mechanically carrying out rites for the sake of “community” or “tradition”—as normal to want and possible to achieve, with no obligation to become a conservative or a Deepak Chopra shill.

That being said, I’m happy she had the experience, and I have to acknowledge most modern churches and synagogues wouldn’t have helped her get there at all. (Western Buddhist and Hindu communities, on the other hand, are great at minting new believers and feeding them back to their ancestral religions.7) Most other religion-surrogates focus on intensity at the expense of substance, so she’s SOL there too. But theater is magical enough to fill the meaning gap. If you believe that LARP is meant to shake people up from their ordinary life, creating space for religious experience is a worthy design goal—and if you don’t, why bother making one?

1

Interestingly, most Nordic LARPs demand relatively little financial sacrifice for the intensity of experience they provide. Most games I saw were several days long, with realistic props and settings, high staff to player ratios, and food and lodging included. But most cost €100-300 to play, with few games over €500 and ubiquitous volunteer discounts. Even after adjusting for inflation, it’s impressive how much these games accomplish on fairly low budgets.

2

More Hinterland narratives here and here.

3

Strangely, other De Sade works are listed as influences but not 120 Days, even though the central plot conceit is the same.

4

Two players got (real life) married in by an Elvis impersonator in Vegas!

5

I haven’t come across the phrase “immersion closet” elsewhere. It sounds kind of derogatory but I don’t think it is meant to be?

6

Immersive religious roleplay raises a lot of questions that lack easy answers. If you pray in a LARP, while absored enough to forget you are LARPing, are you praying in real life? I think there are some Christian schools of thought where accepting Jesus as your lord and savior once is enough to be saved—does he care if you did it in Snapphaneland?

7

Has anyone tried a Buddhist monastery LARP with several hours of real silent sitting a day yet?